Daily brief: France threatens early Afghanistan pullout

By Andrew Lebovich Share

Wonk Watch: Steve Coll, "Looking for Mullah Omar" (New Yorker).

Dangerous bloodshed

French President Nicolas Sarkozy threatened to pull French forces out of Afghanistan early on Friday after four French soldiers were killed in the eastern province of Kapisa by an Afghan soldier (WSJ, Guardian, AP, BBC, Tel, Reuters). He also said that he was sending Defense Minister Gérard Longuet and France's army chief to Afghanistan to begin an inquiry into the safety of French troops there, and that all training and combat support operations would be suspended until the review is finished. The Times' Matthew Rosenberg reports on a classified assessment that found an increased number of killings of international troops by members of the Afghan security forces (NYT). And six U.S. soldiers were killed Thursday when their helicopter crashed in the southern province of Helmand (BBC, Tel, Guardian, Reuters, AP).  

Afghan President Hamid Karzai's chief of staff Abdul Karim Khurram expressed concern to the Times Friday that Afghanistan's government was not being kept fully informed about talks with the Taliban, echoing concern among Afghan and American officials at the pace of such negotiations (NYT, Post, AP). Reuters reveals growing anger among Taliban fighters about the perceived muted response of their leaders to a video that surfaced last week showing U.S. Marines apparently urinating on Taliban corpses (Reuters). And the Afghan government will investigate reports that six civilians, including four children, were killed in by NATO aircraft in Kunar (CNN).  

Finally, at least 29 people have been killed since Monday as a result of devastating avalanches in the northern province of Badakhshan (AP).  

In the flesh

Pakistani-American businessman Mansoor Ijaz was granted a visa to travel to Pakistan Thursday after a personal visit to Pakistan's High Commission in London, allowing Ijaz to travel to Pakistan to tell his side of the story in the "Memogate" affair (Dawn, ET, DT). Ijaz will testify January 24 in front of a judicial commission investigating the incident, but said Friday that the parliamentary committee looking into the same topic cannot summon him to testify, since he is not a Pakistani citizen (ET). Pakistani Interior Minister Rehman Malik said Friday that the government was ready to offer Ijaz protection in Pakistan, while Pakistan's Attorney General Maulvi Anwarul Haq denied Friday before the country's Supreme Court that the government wanted to remove army chief Gen. Ashfaq Parvez Kayani and intelligence head Lt. Gen. Ahmad Shuja Pasha (Dawn, ET, Dawn).   

An anonymous U.S. official told press sources Thursday that a January 10 drone attack in Pakistan killed al-Qaeda's "external operations planner," a Pakistani who may have spent several years in Britain named Aslam Awan (Reuters, NYT, AP, CNN). Meanwhile, the review board of the Lahore High Court has ordered the release of the former leader of the anti-Shi'a militant group Lashkar-e-Jhangvi, Malik Ishaq (ET). And armed men on Thursday kidnapped two European aid workers, a German and an Italian, from the Punjabi city of Multan (NYT, Dawn, BBC, ET).  

Pakistani Prime Minister Yousaf Raza Gilani said Friday that the country's parliament would be the one to make an eventual decision about re-opening border crossings to NATO supplies destined for Afghanistan, a day after anonymous officials said the crossings would be re-opened (Dawn, Reuters, Reuters). And the AP reports that it costs the United States six times as much to send supplies into Afghanistan using routes that do not pass through Pakistan (AP).  

And Norway's head of intelligence, Janne Kristiansen, has resigned after inadvertently disclosing during a parliamentary hearing that Norway has agents working in Pakistan (BBC).  

Cricket king 

The International Cricket Council (ICC) has named Pakistani bowler Saeed Ajmal the world's top-ranked "spinner," after he led Pakistan to a test match victory against England (AP). The match was part of a three-test series, which Pakistan now leads 1-0.

Sign up here to receive the Daily Brief in your inbox. Follow the AfPak Channel on Twitter and Facebook.

CHARLES PLATIAU/AFP/Getty Images

 

MARTY MARTEL

4:55 PM ET

January 20, 2012

Democracies on the run against terror

Would France feel better if its soldiers were killed by Taliban terrorists from across the border supported again by US/NATO-ally Pakistan? NATO including France has to face the fact that its troops are also being killed by the enemy that is sheltered and supported by their so-called ally of last ten years.

Having said that, if France does decide to withdraw its troops from Afghanistan, then it would be grim reminder of how fast US evacuated from Beirut in 1982 after some 200 of its troops were killed in a single bombing.

No wonder Pakistan-supported Taliban is waiting for the end of 2014 when US is expected to leave Afghanistan.

This is the Vietnam lesson – Western democracies do not have stamina or the staying power to see the war through no matter how long it lasts.

Would Hitler’s Nazis be ruling the world now if only he would have invaded Soviet Union after finishing Britain off first?

 

REALITYHURTS

11:03 AM ET

January 21, 2012

if

Very prudent decision

 

TARQUINIS

12:46 PM ET

January 21, 2012

Geez Marty, give it up!

I guess some people find the prospect of an unending Peoples War in land locked central Asia as a salubrious and justified venture. As a test for Western determination. Even if there is no feasible mission, and therefore, no feasible strategy to accomplish it. Not even to mention, that there is no way to get there (with reference to logistics) other than through Pakistan, or Russia.

Perhaps this is not the place for a victory Marty? Has that ever occurred to you?

Marty posts frequently that the problem is Pakistan. That they are playing a double game, and that they are very bad folks. And that is the problem. Got any solutions Marty? Like maybe we should nuke em'? Think that would help quite a bit? Or maybe, just a nice conventional invasion? Just like fighting the Nazis, Marty? That analogy seems to pop up frequently in your commentary.

It is beyond dispute that the one clear result of this endless and pointless war in Afghanistan has been the progressive if not fatal destabilization of Pakistan. Bear in mind there were few major anti-governmental terrorist bombings in that country before this war began, and now they are commonplace with huge civilian death counts as we have recently seen.

Before this war, there were zero attacks of significance on the Punjabi Pak army, and now they must conduct major military campaigns against the fiercest elements of their whole population. Hundreds of thousands have been displaced in the result of such ongoing campaigns.

The Pakistanis know all this if we do not. It is the primary reason why they are DEEPLY conflicted by this war, are playing a double game via the ISI, and support our efforts in Afghanistan only to the degree they must. After all, we directly threatened to blast them into oblivion if they did not.

I argue that in terms of our true security interests, there is far more to lose in the fatal destabilization of Pakistan, than ever to gain in Afghanistan. This war is counterproductive to our real interests.

We have seen this movie before. We all know how it will end.

 

NAEEM AKHTER

7:22 PM ET

January 21, 2012

Real Resolution

The real solution is very complicated and very easy as well if we really want to resolve it. First thing first we should resolve the issues between India and Pakistan at all costs which is the root cause of all problems in the region, especially the cold war between RAA and ISI.

Pakistan should also put her house in order and should focus on internal security and put more modern resources to spying and eliminating the destabalizing factors in the country, there has to be zero tolerance for terrorists and other factors in Paksitan.

Pakistan also has to shift her capital back to Karachi to establish the rit of the governent over all of the country because time has told that Islamabad has not proved right and effective capital for Pakistan at all.