The AFPAK Channel
Inside the war for central asia Twitter Facebook RSS
Daily Brief Latest from the Blog Latest from FP

Daily brief: German army plans fall Afghan offensive

By Andrew Lebovich, August 11, 2010 Share

Uneasy allies

The German army plans to stage an offensive in October alongside Afghan forces to clear Taliban from villages in northern Afghanistan (WSJ). Germany has come under criticism for being too passive in fighting the Taliban in their zone of responsibility, and army leaders want in part to dispel the notion that Germans are unwilling to fight the Taliban. The New York Times today has a must-read on the difficulty of engaging in counterinsurgency around the city of Kunduz while U.S. forces try to learn to trust their erstwhile Afghan partners (NYT). 

After last week's U.N. decision to remove individuals and organizations linked to the Taliban and al Qaeda from an international blacklist, Afghanistan's National Security Council has reportedly asked the U.N. to remove more names of Taliban leaders (AFP).

Two suicide bombers targeted a guest house in Kabul run by the Hart private security firm yesterday, killing two drivers but failing to breach the guest house's protection before detonating their explosives (NYT, VOA, Wash Post, AFP). And three Afghan civilians were killed when their car struck a roadside bomb in Ghazni province (CNN, AP).

Unexpected enemies

In a leaked email exchange released yesterday, five prominent human rights groups including Amnesty International and the International Crisis Group wrote a letter to WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange urging the latter to redact the names of Afghans who worked with international forces from thousands of documents released online (Guardian, BBC, Independent, Tel). The exchange prompted angry retorts from Assange, who demanded that Amnesty provide staff to help search through the documents, and the WikiLeaks Twitter account ran a message saying that Amnesty International, "is primary [sic] funded by the occupying forces of Afghanistan" (CNN).

Amnesty also called yesterday for the Taliban to be tried for war crimes, a move that would have consequences for reconciliation efforts (AP).

The deluge

Pakistan's Chief of Army Staff Gen. Ashfaq Kiyani visited inundated parts of Balochistan, Sindh and Punjab province on Tuesday, as forecasters predicted yet more rain, and relief efforts continue to test the capacity of Pakistan's government (Dawn, CNN, NYT, Dawn). The flooding has done extensive damage not only to Pakistan's infrastructure and electricity generation but also to agriculture, and the government announced it will waive farm loans and help rebuild houses destroyed in the deluge as food prices keep rising (Bloomberg, AJE). The flooding has also sparked a debate over a 40-year old proposal to build a giant dam on the Indus river (WSJ).

The United States yesterday increased its aid to Pakistan to $55 million, and clearing weather in the Swat Valley has allowed the resumption of U.S. helicopter rescue and relief missions (AP, Dawn, NPR). Pakistani Taliban spokesman Azam Tariq told Pakistanis to refuse the aid, saying instead that the Taliban will provide for them (AP, AFP, Reuters, Daily Times). And despite the increase in U.S. aid the U.N. and Oxfam report that only $45 million has been given to Pakistan by the international community with another $91 million pledged, numbers far below donations for previous crises in Pakistan and elsewhere (Wash Post, BBC, ET). India has reportedly given no aid to Pakistan, with its high commission in London indicating that the country has not made a decision about providing flood assistance (Guardian).

Pakistani President Asif Ali Zardari has an op-ed in yesterday's Wall Street Journal responding to criticism of his absence during Pakistan's crisis, writing, "I chose to use my travels to mobilize foreign assistance-money, supplies, food, tents, medical care, engineers, clean water and medicine-for our people. Some have criticized my decision...but I felt that I had to choose substance over symbolism" (WSJ). And two more killings in Karachi have brought the death toll there since last Monday to at least 104 (Daily Times).

Flashpoint

Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh went on T.V. to call for an end to the "cycle of violence" in Kashmir, as anger grows among Kashmiri separatists against India's protest-breaking tactics (BBC, Reuters). Separately, U.S. defense officials, including Undersecretary for Defense Michèle Flournoy told Indian reporters that the United States was monitoring how Pakistan used arms given by the United States for combating terrorism (AFP). Flournoy also said that the United States was only providing unarmed drone aircraft to Pakistan (ToI).

The honey trap


Pakistan's Daily Times reports that Pakistani police are baiting men with women, before catching the men "red-handed" with the women and demanding bribes (Daily Times).

Sign up here to receive the daily brief in your inbox. Follow the AfPak Channel on Twitter and Facebook.

Miguel Villagran/Getty Images

 

MARTY MARTEL

10:23 AM ET

August 11, 2010

NO chance of success for West's Afghan mission

German army may plan an offensive in Northern Afghanistan but as long as US, the main leader of this Afghan mission continues to mollycoddle Pakistan, the chief instigator of Taliban insurgency, there is NO chance of success for Karzai government to survive Pakistan-sponsored Taliban onslaught.

As long as US government and news media continue to ignore Taliban’s Pakistani connections in fueling and sustaining Afghan insurgency as reported by Matt Waldman in ‘The sun in the sky‘ on 6/13/10, corroborated by WikiLeaks leaks on 7/25/10 and then further corroborated by Chris Alexander, Canadian ambassador to Afghanistan from 2003 to 2005 and Deputy Special Representative of the UN Secretary-General for Afghanistan from 2005 until 2009 in his article on 7/30/10 titled ‘The huge scale of Pakistan‘s complicity‘, problems faced by US Afghan mission will continue to not only persist but compound.

All American officers in southern Afghanistan know that they can not prevail in the ongoing military operations, unless Taliban strongholds across the Durand Line in North Waziristan and Baluchistan are neutralized. Adm Mullen and Gen Patraeus evidently do not want to acknowledge that hard options have to be considered if their soldiers are not to die at the hands of radicals, armed and trained across the Durand Line. This is where rubber meets the road for the famous General.

As Matt Waldman reported, “support for the Afghan Taliban is ‘official Pakistani ISI policy’ and is backed at the highest levels of Pakistan’s civilian administration. Pakistan appears to be playing a double game of astonishing magnitude. There is thus a strong case that the ISI orchestrates, sustains and shapes the overall insurgent campaign in Afghanistan.”

The ISI is said to compensate families of suicide bombers to the tune of 200,000 Pakistani rupees, claims the report. Thus US aid to bankrupt Pakistan finances the death of US/NATO soldiers in Afghanistan. So in a way, US is financing the death of its own troops in Afghanistan.

Pakistani government issued its usual denials just as it had denied umpteen times the existence of Mullah Mohammed Omar’s ‘Quetta Shura Taliban (QST)’ in the provincial capital Quetta of Baluchistan. But General Stanley McChrystal called QST as the biggest threat to US Afghan mission in his report to President Obama in August, 2009.

Pakistan has denied presence of Osama bin Laden on Pakistani soil umpteen times and just recently Adm Mike Mullen repeated in Islamabad that Osama is hiding in a very secure place in Pakistan.

The most breath-taking part of this sordid saga is that US is NOT holding Pakistan responsible for sheltering, protecting and supporting Haqqani’s HQN network and Mullah Omar’s QST network all these years while those networks have been causing daily deaths of US/NATO soldiers ever since 2002 even though Pakistan was SUPPOSED to have joined US fight against same Taliban back in 2001!

 

LEILA KHAN

1:25 AM ET

August 12, 2010

More reasons.

The US cannot and will not hold Pakistan responsible for any accusations involving supporting the Taliban in Pakistan or Afghanistan. The reason being, Pakistan is their own hope towards winning this war and if they try to blame the ISI or the Pakistani government, they know it will only lead to the end of the war for them. Also, Pakistan has not only been a victim of terrorism itself, a huge amount of soldiers have died and their military capacity does not allow them to do more than they are already.
As far as the war itself is concerned, Zareed Zakaria on his show GPS on July 4th, 2010 reported that there are only 100 Al-Qaeda members left in Afghanistan. In this case, doesn't it seem suspicious to think, why is the US spending millions of dollars and sacrificing millions of deaths for a 100 militants?
The reason/s for the invasion is a much bigger picture than it seems to be.