The AFPAK Channel
Inside the war for central asia Twitter Facebook RSS
Daily Brief Latest from the Blog Latest from FP

Voice from Kashmir

By Hafsa Kanjwal, July 12, 2010 Share

Over the weekend, the Indian government imposed, lifted, imposed, and lifted another curfew in the Indian-administered region of Kashmir. For the past month, the region has faced some of the largest protests since 2008. I have been in Srinagar, the capital city of Kashmir, since June 16, shortly after the latest round of tension began. There is not much coverage of the recent events in the international media, which is unfortunate as the situation in Kashmir is contextually, inextricably linked to developments in Afghanistan and Pakistan.

Protests have become a regular occurrence in the Kashmir Valley; the people call for freedom and an end to the Indian presence in Kashmir, but over the last few weeks, the violence has been escalating. On June 11, the local police in Kashmir killed a 17-year-old boy, named Tufail, who was walking home carrying a backpack amidst a protest in downtown Kashmir and was hit at close range with a tear gas canister. The next day, the main newspaper in the area reported that eyewitnesses said he was shot, though Indian police called his death "mysterious." During another related protest shortly after, another young Kashmiri man was injured, and died a few days later in a hospital. At his funeral, his cousin Javed was also shot and killed by Indian security forces. In the past several weeks, Indian forces have killed at least fifteen young men and injured or arrested many more. Security forces seem to be everywhere in Kashmir, especially at large gatherings of people and funerals. At many funerals, those bearing the body of the dead begin chanting anti-Indian slogans, and the services double as protests as well as memorials.

While all of this was happening, the region's main political parties called for a hartaal, or strike in which Kashmiris shut down their businesses, and no one goes to work. Schools, banks, government buildings, and transportation are also completely shut down. During the hartaal, from June 12 to July 5, protests erupted throughout the valley and are still being violently quelled by the Indian army and local police. However, in the past week, the situation has taken a turn for the worse and the government has imposed a curfew -- which means that no one is allowed to move outside. Many areas have defied the curfew and protests still ensue. Local police and Indian security forces blame the outbursts on the youth and their "stone-throwing." Local police seem ill-equipped for controlling large groups and continue to fire into unarmed crowds.

Even as I write this, I can hear shots from a distance -- whether they are from the tear gas that is dispersed into the crowds or actual bullets, I can't tell anymore. I keep hearing army convoys driving through the city -- I've counted at least fifteen in the past half an hour alone. One night last week around midnight, I listened to a protest, hearing shouts of azaadi (freedom), announcements from the loudspeakers of the nearby mosques, and then the sounds of the Indian army trucks as they moved towards the direction of the protest. Most of Kashmir's residents can't really be sure what is happening outside, as the government has blocked most major media outlets.

The media censorship began once the violence started -- the local TV news hour was cut to a mere ten minutes -- in hopes that the news being reported would not rile people up even further. It was completely stopped for several days, though the short broadcasts have since returned. For a while, the only means of knowing what was going on over the past few weeks was the print newspaper, but even the newspapers stopped printing for a few days (though they resumed this morning). Cell-phone services in the volatile areas are restricted. Text messaging services all across Kashmir are also blocked. Last week, Indian authorities also refused to issue curfew passes to Kashmiri journalists, and now even the local reporters are unable to cover these stories. Just a few days ago, we heard reports of a dozen photojournalists being beaten and severely injured by the Indian forces as they were covering the funeral of one of the young boys who was killed.

The media coverage I've seen focuses almost entirely on the "stone-throwing" of the young men and allusions are made to the suspicious role of Pakistan in sponsoring this "rogue, extremist" behavior. A journalist who is particularly disliked in Kashmir is Barkha Dutt from India's NDTV, who recently interviewed the head of a faction of the Hurriyet conference, the alliance of major pro-independence groups in Kashmir. Mirwaiz Umar Farooq asserted, "No military will be able to break the will and the resolve of the people of Kashmir," and called for a political solution to the conflict. Anchors like Dutt seem to have no idea, or don't want to have an idea, about the aspirations and wishes of the people here in Srinagar. Nearly everyone in Kashmir wants independence.

My family here has become used to the situation. I'm currently staying with my mom's side of the family in Srinagar. My grandparents need to get some medicines from the pharmacy, but we have been unable to move outside because of the curfew. My little cousin, who is seven years old, hasn't gone to school for the past three weeks. She asked her mother the other day to make a special prayer to God that she would be allowed to start school again soon. My uncle, who is a physician and runs his own private clinic, has stopped going to work. During the days of the hartaal, when it is too dangerous to move around, he would leave early in the morning to evade the protests, but then return around noon as none of the patients were able to come.

But what is most heartbreaking for me is my dad's side of the family, who lives in Sopore, less than an hour away from Srinagar. Sopore is considered to be the "Gaza" of Kashmir by locals. A number of the boys who were killed in recent weeks were from Sopore, and since I've arrived, the entire city has been placed on curfew -- not just hartaal. There are protests there regularly and encounters between the locals and the army. I have not been able to see my grandmother nor my extended family there. Because of the curfew, their food items are severely restricted -- so they're surviving on the little amount they grow in their gardens or trying to make do with their neighbors. They don't tell me much the few times we have been able to talk; they don't want me to worry. But my cousin there is 14 years old -- and I worry about him.

The situation in downtown Srinagar, just a few kilometers from where I'm sitting, is similar. Locals have also been under curfew for the past three weeks as downtown is where most of the protests happen. There is a shortage of food -- water, milk, meat, bread.

The few times we were able to move around, I met with a few leaders of NGOs here. It is difficult for them to operate in such conditions. Their plans for the week are completely interrupted and they're unable to move ahead on their projects. Their sense of helplessness is palpable -- in these circumstances they are completely unable to provide relief or aid to the most impoverished populations here.

It is difficult to tell what will happen here over the next few weeks. But like the violence, the cycle of disappointment also exists. The Indian government might be able to quell the situation momentarily and make claims about how it is serious about the "peace process" and dialogue with Pakistan. Then, the process will be delayed. Meanwhile, the cycle of violence will continue.

Hafsa Kanjwal is a graduate of Georgetown's School of Foreign Service who was born in Indian-administered Kashmir. She will begin her doctoral studies in history and women's studies at the University of Michigan this fall.

ROUF BHAT/AFP/Getty Images

 
Facebook|Twitter|Reddit

NORBOOSE

3:05 PM ET

July 12, 2010

Does Kashmir have any real value?

Is it just symbolic and political? Does it have any economic or strategic importance? I think its like the US and China with Taiwan: Both use it as a political tool and both use a lot of meaningless high-minded talk, while neither government actually cares much about changing the situation. China scores domestic points by whining, and the US cant let it go or it would lose domestic points. Pakistan wins domestic points by whining and India cant let it go, least it lose those precious domestic points. Yes, they are real people, and there may be a better and worse side, but thats all pretty irrelevent to how one should actually deal with the situation to change it.

 

GLYNCH23

3:53 PM ET

July 12, 2010

Al-Qaeda aims to cash in on Kashmir

http://www.atimes.com/atimes/South_Asia/LG13Df02.html

While it is terrible to see the latest round of violence, the author is missing the main impediment of any sort of deal or peaceful resolution to Kashmir....it's Pakistan's army and intelligence services and their use and support of terrorism.

India want's to do a deal. In 1999 both India and Pakistan's civilian government had initiated the Lahore Declaration and were negotiating all issues, including Kashmir. But, as this was developing, then Army General Musharraf dressed up Pakistani soldiers as "freedom fighters" and tried to take over Kashmir. Pakistan 's army was exposed for their role and was forced to retreat. This war is now known as Kargil.

Kargil was followed by a number of acts of terror, including the 1999 Air India Hijacking and the bombing of the Indian Parlement. Both terrorist attacks had ties to supposed Kashmiri jihadi groups.

What is forgotten is the the goodwill generated by the negotiations was thrown away because of Pakistan's acts of terror.

Almost 9 years later Musharraf, then the Prime Minister, tried to initiate similar back-channel talks with Indian, in regards to resolving Kashmir. Once again, the terrorist/military nexus in Pakistan wrecked any hope of some sort of dialogue, as terrorists took over the Red Mosque and ruined the political environment and/or support Musharraf needed to continue with the peace talks.

Then, of course, the Mumbai attacks were launched from Pakistan, with support from the ISI and the Pakistani military, with no forthcoming resolution.

India wants to do strike a deal. They have tried in earnest, twice in the past 10 years.

In 1989 450,000 Hindu Kashmiri's were kicked out of their home. Pakistan was one of three countries to recognize and support the Taliban. Pakistan-administered Kashmir is now full of terrorist camps.

If there is peace that is to come to Kashmir, it will be because Pakistan actually tackles the terrorists operating with their support on their soil.

It's Pakistan's support and use of terrorism that is continuing this cycle....and the story below suggests peace won't be coming anytime soon.

http://www.atimes.com/atimes/South_Asia/LG13Df02.html

 

NPEGASUS

2:07 AM ET

July 13, 2010

Good observation

Glynch23:

You've covered the limitations of solving the issue well.

 

MILANSHEKUE

7:36 AM ET

July 13, 2010

Kashmir needs to be free

Glynch: you are absolutely wrong in tying Kashmir and AlQaeda together. There has never been any AlQaeda presence in Kashmir. Indian government has repeatedly denied its presence. Many times Hindu zealots try to project Kashmir struggle for freedom as fundamentalist, but they have no proof or even basis to say so. Kashmiris are mostly Muslim, but Kashmiris follow a sufi Islam, which promotes values of trust, hospitality, and peace. Kashmir has been an issue since long before any radical Islamist group emerged. Please don't mislead others by your baseless propaganda. If there ever was any radical person in Kashmir, it was only in reaction to the rise of Hindu fundamentalists in India. Indian government purpotedly presents itself as secular, but everyone knows the condition of India's minorities, especially Muslims (did you forget genocide in Gujarat in 2002?), Christians (remember Kandhamal, remember Father Graham Steins and his two sons, how they burned alive by hindu fanatics) and Dalits. Even Sikhs were not spared (remember the massacres of 1984). It is this growing Hindu fascism in India which makes it even more urgent that Kashmir becomes free. Hindi fascists would want to commit genocide of Kashmiris, they have already demanded repeal of article 370. 10 million Kashmiris are right now forced to live under India through a military occupation which is illegal, unreasonable, and immoral.

 

MILANSHEKUE

7:40 AM ET

July 13, 2010

Kashmir needs to be free

Glynch: you are absolutely wrong in tying Kashmir and AlQaeda together. There has never been any AlQaeda presence in Kashmir. Indian government has repeatedly denied its presence. Many times Hindu zealots try to project Kashmir struggle for freedom as fundamentalist, but they have no proof or even basis to say so. Kashmiris are mostly Muslim, but Kashmiris follow a sufi Islam, which promotes values of trust, hospitality, and peace. Kashmir has been an issue since long before any radical Islamist group emerged. Please don't mislead others by your baseless propaganda. If there ever was any radical person in Kashmir, it was only in reaction to the rise of Hindu fundamentalists in India. Indian government purpotedly presents itself as secular, but everyone knows the condition of India's minorities, especially Muslims (did you forget genocide in Gujarat in 2002?), Christians (remember Kandhamal, remember Father Graham Steins and his two sons, how they burned alive by hindu fanatics) and Dalits. Even Sikhs were not spared (remember the massacres of 1984). It is this growing Hindu fascism in India which makes it even more urgent that Kashmir becomes free. Hindi fascists would want to commit genocide of Kashmiris, they have already demanded repeal of article 370. 10 million Kashmiris are right now forced to live under India through a military occupation which is illegal, unreasonable, and immoral.

 

NPEGASUS

2:03 PM ET

July 13, 2010

Plant a bomb & get yourself heard on the FP magazine

MILANSHEKUE:

I like how you peddle your one-sided views and accuse others of propaganda in the same comment. Kashmir is a mosaic of different communities where the demand for independence is just one view. The other strong view is the demand for more autonomy and not independence. Ironically, when people who claim to be Sufis of Kashmir plant bombs and pelt stones the views other Sufis, who disagree, are muzzled. And, I have not even touched upon the views of people in Jammu and Ladakh who vehemently oppose independence but do not pelt stones to make them heard. Consequently, their views do not qualify for the respectable Foreign Policy magazine.

The Sufi version of Islam is on the retreat in Kashmir for decades and steadily replaced by an extremist version, the Saudi import variety. Otherwise, how would you explain the planned and forced expulsion of Hindus and the subsequent reluctance to accept them back? India may not have a perfect record in treatment of its minorities but it has done far better job than that of any other country in the region.

 

NPEGASUS

1:47 AM ET

July 13, 2010

Err....haven't you missed out something important?

I read about the sinister plans that many teenage boys (aka protestors) were paid money by the miscreants to pelt stones at the local police. Which means a tragic incidence was exploited by the miscreants to create mayhem that can be later blamed it on the state. Consequently, the Kashmir police had to respond to an unruly crowd - many paid professionals - with a heavy hand which led to more unfortunate deaths. I see that you have missed out the critical turn of events.

 

MILANSHEKUE

7:44 AM ET

July 13, 2010

No proof, Indian government lies through its teeth

There is no proof of money being paid to protestors. It is all Indian govt's propaganda. No individual can put his or her life in absolute danger for a few bucks. Where is your morality! People.

 

NPEGASUS

1:07 PM ET

July 13, 2010

Buy a protest and pelt a stone, Kashmir style

Like millions of others, I read the transcripts and saw the confession of the accussed. It was not a propoganda. Stone pelting, sadly, is a business in Kashmir where teenagers throng on the streets and pelt stones in return for either money or adrelanine rush. This creates mayhem where the masterminds of violence use it as a camouflage of civil disobedience. When violence is planted by the miscreants for political mileage, curfew is the benign option for any government.

 

MILANSHEKUE

1:46 PM ET

July 13, 2010

NPEGASUS ---Indian propaganda continues

Yes yes you have watched mistranslated intercept on Indian media channels. But what you ignore completely and wlfully is that protests didn't emerge in thin air. Three people were shot dead by India's occupation army men in Kupwara in cold blood, and then labelled them as terrorists. That is what provoked protests. Stop this propaganda. No lies can prevent the noble idea of independence and march of freedom to move forward in Kashmir. India should focus on its real problems. BBC just reported India has more poor than all of Africa combined. Why is India spending billions on a military occupation which is extremely popular and doomed to fail? A military mindset, and try to solve every issue with military logic will break India up completely. Aren't you seeing what is happening in Central India. In a world where military force is becoming increasingly unpopular, India will have to listen to the democratic will of the nation of Kashmir. And they have made it resoundingly clear, they want INDEPENDENCE. They don't care about India or Pakistan. They care about Kashmir.

 

NPEGASUS

2:43 PM ET

July 13, 2010

Facts and propoganda

MILANSHUKE,

In your book, every other view is a propoganda, isn't it? I did not watch or read about the confessions on the Indian media alone, so please spare me from your rant. India has never used its military might in Kashmir; deployment of security police for patroling? yes; military might? no. The recent deaths were tragic but so were the sinister plans of the seperatists to kill more of their own by planting mayem on the streets.

In reality, there is no march to freedom in Kashmir. What we have is a potent mixture of the combination of some hooligans, out-of-work seperatists, political shenanigans and foreign funding. Sure, the majority in Kashmir wants peace, autonomy and normalcy. So does everyone else.

 

GLYNCH23

12:38 PM ET

July 13, 2010

a response to "Kashmir needs to be free"

Yes, India has had a long and tortured history, stricken with ethnic strife, religious oppression etc

The gujurat riots were disgusting, as were the 1984 sikh riots etc

With respect to Kashmir, everyone recognizes that a solution other than the status quo must be reached. The current situation of Kashmir is not acceptable.

India has tried, twice, within the last 12 years. Both times were thrown off because of terrorist acts launched by Pakistan.

The parameters of the deal are known. There is an eagerness to breakthrough and achieve peace from the Indian government.

What the entire world has to guard against is what happens "the day after" any deal is reached. The head of the LeT has vowed to ramp up the Jihad throughout India. In the 1990's the Pakistan was one of three countries to recognize the draconian government of the Taliban. "Azad" Kashmir, or the Pakistani side of Kashmir, is brimming with terrorist camps. As bad as the situation is right now in Kashmir, it would get overrun by terrorists unless......

Kashmir can be "freed", if and only if Pakistan actually does a complete U Turn and confronts and kills the terrorist infrastructure that it currently employs. The Jaish-A-Mohammed, the LeT and the rest, from the leaders of the group on down.

If that day comes, Kashmir's situation would dramatically change.

 

MARTY MARTEL

1:19 PM ET

July 13, 2010

Meek Sonia-Singh government buckles under US pressure

Increased violence in Kashmir is Pakistan’s reward for India restarting the peace dialogue under US pressure.

It is the naïve Sonia-Singh government’s free hand to separatists and appeasement of Muslim voters as well as mollycoddling of Pakistan under US pressure that are creating J&K’s problems. India spends more money per capita for development in Kashmir than any other Indian state.

Home Minister Chidamabaram and foreign secretary Rao visit Islamabad while Pakistani Army and Rangers fire along LoC/IB to aid terrorist infiltration that cause havoc in Kashmir! So India is literally talking to Pakistan under a barrel of a gun when it does not have to but for US pressure.

This meek Indian government has neither the guts nor the desire to solve the Kashmir problem - they just want to let it fester more and more so that one day it becomes unbearable and Manmohan rushes to Islamabad with his turban in his hand and beg Pakistan to take over Kashmir.

Having elected and reelected such a docile UPA government, Indian voters have nobody to blame but themselves for such a sorry state of affairs in Kashmir.

 

NPEGASUS

2:57 PM ET

July 13, 2010

Good that you now have computers

Aurangzeb Khan,

There was no Pakistan thousand years before. But, it's heartening to see the US tax payers money is being put to good use to buy computers in Pakistan; the next step should be to actually buy text books in Madrassas and public schools there to bring people in to the 21st century.

 

GLYNCH23

2:48 PM ET

July 16, 2010

ISI paid Rs25L to LeT to buy boat for 26/11 attack: Headley

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/ISI-paid-Rs25L-to-LeT-to-buy-boat-for-26/11-attack-Headley/articleshow/6177389.cms

The military/terrorist complex in Pakistan is responsible for the support of the Tailiban throughout the 1990's, the London Tube Bombers, the failed Times Square Bomber, and the Mumbai attacks, amongst others.

If the day comes when this complex is destroyed, peace can be achieved in Kashmir.

 

BUYNFLSHOP

1:18 AM ET

July 20, 2010

buynflshop

Wholesale NFL Jerseys
Cheap NFL Jerseys
NFL Jerseys
NFL Football Jerseys
Women NFL Jerseys
Kid NFL Jerseys
Super Bowl Jerseys
Super Bowl NFL Jerseys
Throwback Jerseys
Throwback NFL Jerseys
Cheap Throwback Jerseys
Wholesale Throwback Jerseys
Cheap Super Bowl Jerseys
Wholesale Super Bowl Jerseys
youth nfl jerseys wholesale
youth nfl jerseys cheap
nfl youth jerseys
Baltimore Ravens Jerseys
Chicago Bears Jerseys
Cincinnati Bengals Jerseys
Denver Broncos Jerseys
Dallas Cowboys Jerseys
Green Bay Packers Jerseys
Indianapolis Colts Jerseys
Minnesota Vikings Jerseys
New England Patriots Jerseys
New Orleans Saints Jerseys
New York Jets Jerseys
Arizona Cardinals Jerseys
Buffalo Bills Jerseys
Atlanta Falcons Jerseys
Carolina Panthers Jerseys
Cleveland Browns Jerseys
Houston Texans Jerseys
Detroit Lions Jerseys
Jacksonville Jaguars Jerseys
Kansas City Chiefs Jerseys
Miami Dolphins Jerseys
New York Giants Jerseys
Philadelphia Eagles Jerseys
San Francisco 49ers Jerseys
Oakland Raiders Jerseys
Seattle Seahawks Jerseys
Pittsburgh Steelers Jerseys
St Louis Rams Jerseys
San Diego Chargers Jerseys
Tampa Bay Buccaneers Jerseys
Tennessee Titans Jerseys
Washington Redskins Jerseys
Ray Lewis Jerseys
Ed Reed Jerseys
Joe Flacco Jerseys
Terrell Suggs Jerseys
Dick Butkus Jerseys
Greg Olsen Jerseys
Matt Forte Jerseys
Devin Hester Jerseys
Walter Payton Jerseys
Brian Urlacher Jerseys
Lance Briggs Jerseys
Jay Cutler Jerseys
Carson Palmer Jerseys
Rey Maualuga Jerseys
Chad Johnson Jerseys
Demarcus Ware Jerseys
Jason Witten Jerseys
Terrell Owens Jerseys
Felix Jones Jerseys
Marion Barber Navy Jerseys
Marion Barber Jerseys
Emmitt Smith Jerseys
Miles Austin Jerseys
Roger Staubach Jerseys
Troy Aikman Jerseys
Tony Romo Jerseys
Eddie Royal Jerseys
Brandon Marshall Jerseys
Aaron Rodgers Jerseys
A.J. Hawk Jerseys
Donald Driver Jerseys
Greg Jennings Jerseys
Peyton Manning Jerseys
Dallas Clark Jerseys
Robert Mathis Jerseys
Marvin Harrison Jerseys
Drew Brees Jerseys
Marques Colston Jerseys
Pierre Thomas Jerseys
Reggie Bush Jerseys
Jeremy Shockey Jerseys
Tarvaris Jackson Jerseys
Adrian Peterson Jerseys
Jared Allen Jerseys
Mark Sanchez Jerseys
Thomas Jones Jerseys
Leon Washington Jerseys
Brett Favre Jerseys