The AFPAK Channel
Inside the war for central asia Twitter Facebook RSS
Daily Brief Latest from the Blog Latest from FP

Daily brief: Clinton confirms "strategic partnership" with Karzai

By Andrew Lebovich, May 12, 2010 Share

Diplomatic finery

Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton yesterday hosted Afghan President Hamid Karzai for a day of meetings and a dinner in his honor, calling the American relationship with Afghanistan a "strategic partnernship," praising Karzai's efforts to fight corruption, and vowing not to abandon Afghanistan even after American troops leave (Reuters, Times, Independent, WSJ). Karzai and the 15 cabinet ministers who traveled with him engaged in a series of meetings and smaller working groups with their American counterparts throughout the day; Karzai reportedly presented his plan for reconciliation with Taliban members, in addition to pushing for American support for a "peace jirga," a meeting with 1,500 tribal leaders to be held later this month focusing on Taliban reconciliation (AJE, NYT). Karzai will spend much of today in meetings with President Barack Obama, and the two will hold a joint press conference (BBC, AP).

Karzai is also reportedly pressing for major long-term security commitments to Afghanistan as well as "major non-NATO ally" status, currently accorded to countries like Australia, Israel, Japan, and Pakistan (LAT). The designation would give Afghanistan access to U.S. weapons technology in addition to other benefits, but puts the White House in the sensitive position of wanting to reassure Karzai while maintaining leverage over him. Greg Jaffe and Karen DeYoung also write today that the United States faces a challenge in trying to balance the need for reliable local governments with Karzai's fears of losing authority to local and provincial leaders (Wash Post).

Afghan army woes continue


A forthcoming International Crisis Group (ICG) report concludes that the Afghan National Army (ANA) is riddled with corruption and ethnic factionalism that is slowing its growth and hampering its effectiveness (McClatchy). The report warns that the tension and endemic issues "could risk the army's disintegration after the withdrawal of international forces."

In Kandahar, the Taliban claimed credit for the shooting death of the no. 2 prisons official in the province (AP).

The ties that strain

FBI investigators are reportedly en route to Pakistan to investigate potential ties between failed Times Square bomber Faisal Shahzad and the Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) (Times). Despite assertions from U.S. officials about TTP support for Shahzad, Pakistani investigators say they have found "no Taliban link" to the attacks (Guardian). The attack and U.S. claims of Pakistani responsibility for subduing militant groups has again brought out some Pakistanis' mistrust of the U.S.'s intentions, and Special Envoy for Afghanistan and Pakistan Amb. Richard Holbrooke yesterday said that Secretary of State Hillary Clinton's comments suggesting repercussions in Pakistan in the event of a terrorist attack on the United States were "misinterpreted" (Wash Post, Dawn).

The State Department is considering adding the TTP to its list of banned terrorist groups, a lengthy process that could make it illegal to provide the group material support, freeze its assets in the U.S., and ban its members from traveling here (AP, Reuters, AFP, McClatchy). The announcement came on the same day that five Democratic senators wrote a letter calling for the group's ban. And after receiving a classified briefing on Shahzad's attack, the top Democrats and Republicans on the Senate Intelligence Committee, Senator Dianne Feinstein (R-CA) and Senator Kit Bond (R-MO), urged that the TTP be banned, and rules controlling no-fly lists tightened (NYT). Sen. Bond added, however, that he thought the White House's evidence for the link between the TTP and Shahzad was based on "suspicious and tenuous connections" (Wash Post, Reuters)

Meanwhile, Pakistan's government is trying to garner support among tribal leaders to expel Taliban commanders and fighters from the Mehsud tribe, currently believed to be hiding in South Waziristan (Daily Times).

A bomb exploded in a fuel truck at the Chaman crossing point in Pakistan, destroying thousands of gallons of fuel intended for NATO forces in Afghanistan and killing two civilians (Dawn). And a Pakistani court threw out a motion to block the extradition of top Taliban leaders to Afghanistan, including Quetta Shura Taliban no. 2 Mullah Baradar, after Khalid Khawaja was killed by a militant group that had kidnapped him as well as two others (Reuters, AFP).

The Drone War

Drone strikes continued to pound North Waziristan for the fourth time since the failed Times Square bombing May 1, hitting a militant camp on the Afghan border and killing at least 11 fighters (Dawn, The News, Daily Times). The strikes occurred in an area under the control of local Taliban commander Hafiz Gul Bahadur.

In North Waziristan's main city of Miram Shah, the TTP dumped the bodies of two men it accused of being U.S. "spies" (Dawn). And unknown attackers threw a grenade at a construction site on the outskirts of Peshawar, killing two young girls who were playing inside (AFP, BBC).

Today also brings part two of Paul Cruickshank's and Nic Robertson's CNN special on 'homegrown terrorism' (CNN). For more on links between homegrown terrorists and the tribal areas of Pakistan, see Cruickshank's paper on the "militant pipeline" from the Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATA) to the West (NAF)

Afghanistan's creepiest game

When not on the watch for Taliban, U.S. Army soldiers rotating through a remote Kandahar outpost hunt instead for the things that go bump in the night (AP). Soldiers go out on patrols for snakes, scorpions and giant camel spiders, sometimes helped by mortar crews firing illumination rounds and cheered on by their colleagues.

Sign up here to receive the daily brief in your inbox. Follow the AfPak Channel on Twitter and Facebook.

MARK WILSON/Getty Images

 

SURESH SHETH

4:35 PM ET

May 12, 2010

US mollycoddles Pakistan at the expense of Afghanistan

US can have all the strategic partnership with Afghanistan but it will not matter since Obama administration has continued Bush policy of mollycoddling Pakistan at the expense of Afghanistan.

It is doubtful that Obama can achieve much from this Karzai visit unless Obama administration reins in on Pakistani ambitions to be the ‘kingmaker’ in Afghanistan.

Pakistani government wants to turn back the clock and claim same suzerainty it had over Afghanistan when it installed Taliban government there in 1996. UN report on Bhutto killing released on 4/15/10 confirmed this fact when it noted that "The PAKISTANI MILITARY ORGANIZED AND SUPPORTED THE TALIBAN TO TAKE CONTROL OF AFGHANISTAN IN 1996“. So in a way, Pakistani government was in charge of Afghanistan when 9/11 attacks were carried out and hence Pakistani government was responsible for those attacks. With latest attempt by Faisal Shahzad to bomb New York, things haven’t changed much in Pakistan since 2001. Afterall Richard Armitage had a reason to threaten Musharraf with 'dire consequences' if Pakistan did not join US fight against terrorism in 2001.

When Karzai visited Islamabad on March 10 to find out why his interlocutor Mullah Baradar was arrested, he was, according to Afghan officials, bluntly told by Pakistan's generals that the Americans are bound to leave and that if he wanted Pakistani help resolving issues with the Taliban, he would first have to close Indian consulates in Kandahar and Jalalabad. Pakistani officials deny threatening Karzai and insist that they want a peaceful and stable Afghanistan once the Americans leave. But other sources have confirmed that such ultimatums were delivered. So Pakistani government continues to reject sovereignty of Afghan government to choose its friends no matter what Pakistani government declares publicly.

Both Mr Karzai and Baradar are Durrani Pashtuns, sharing common tribal loyalties. An infuriated Karzai now finds his reconciliation efforts with the Taliban undermined, with the Pakistanis procrastinating on his demand for the extradition of Baradar to Afghanistan. Pakistan, which for years has denied the presence of the Mullah Omar-led ‘Quetta shura’ on its soil, now brazenly demands that it should be the prime intermediary in any process of reconciliation with the Taliban.

Unless the Obama Administration stops Bush’s policy of mollycoddling Pakistan at the expense of Afghanistan, US mission in Afghanistan is headed for failure no matter how much untangling Obama does with Karzai.