The AFPAK Channel
Inside the war for central asia Twitter Facebook RSS
Daily Brief Latest from the Blog Latest from FP

Daily brief: NATO airstrike kills 4 Afghan civilians

By Katherine Tiedemann, April 6, 2010 Share

Picking up the pieces

A day after the first militant attack on a U.S. mission in Pakistan since 2006, U.S. and Pakistani investigators are puzzling over how six Pakistani Taliban militants armed with suicide vests, two car bombs, machine guns, and rocket propelled grenades managed to launch a sophisticated, deadly assault on the U.S. consulate in Peshawar (Dawn/AFP, AFP, NYT, Wash Post, McClatchy, BBC, The News). The U.S. expressed "great concern" over yesterday's attack, which left six Pakistanis dead, and the United Nations has closed its offices in Peshawar today and tomorrow for security reasons. Earlier this morning, Pakistani police killed two suspected suicide bombers on the outskirts of Peshawar (AP).

Clashes between the Pakistani military and militants in Orakzai continue, as helicopter gunships targeted extremist strongholds in Miangano, Kalay, and Handara, and some 235 militants have been killed since the operations began several weeks ago (Daily Times, Reuters). The Journal discusses State Department lawyer Harold Koh's legal defense of U.S. drone strikes in northwest Pakistan, writing that CIA officials claim between 400 and 500 suspected militants have been killed in the strikes since January of 2009, and only 20 civilians (WSJ). Pakistan's Daily Times reports that "indigenously developed" drones were seen flying over the northeastern Pakistani city of Sargodha yesterday (Daily Times).

Karen DeYoung reports that the Pakistani Army's alleged 'extrajudicial killings' in the country's northwestern Swat Valley threatens U.S. aid, which requires Congress to certify that Pakistan is adhering to human rights norms (Wash Post). And the German magazine Der Spiegel profiles some of the nearly 100 Germans who have migrated to North and South Waziristan, both frequently targeted by drone strikes, in the last several years seeking life in the combat zone (Spiegel). For more on the militant pipeline between the West and Pakistan, click this recent paper by investigative reporter Paul Cruickshank (NAF).

Taxi driver


The Pakistani-born U.S. citizen and cab driver in Chicago who is accused of sending money in an attempt to aid al-Qaeda yesterday pleaded not guilty (AP, ToI, Bloomberg). Prosecutors allege that Raja Lahrasib Khan wired $950 to Pakistan last November and accepted $1,000 in unmarked bills from an undercover agent, promising it would be sent to Pakistan to purchase weapons, and Khan could face up to 15 years in prison on each charge.

Air power and politics

A NATO airstrike on a residence in the Nahr-e Saraj area of Afghanistan's southern Helmand province earlier today killed four suspected insurgents and four civilians who were inside the compound unbeknownst to security forces, who were reportedly being fired upon from inside (AFP, AP, ISAF, Pajhwok). Two men, a woman, and a child were killed, and NATO is investigating (Reuters). And yesterday, a Baghlan provincial councilwoman was shot in the leg and abdomen in the latest instance of an attempted targeted assassination by militants, and NATO forces killed 10 militants in a firefight in Nangarhar (AP). Before dawn this morning, a NATO-Afghan offensive in Badghis left 27 Taliban fighters dead in the western province (AP).

White House spokesman Robert Gibbs described Afghan President Hamid Karzai's recent threat to join the Taliban if the West keeps pressuring him to reform as "genuinely troubling" yesterday, though Karzai told CNN that he has no intention of breaking with the United States and said he just wanted to "make sure we all understand as to where each one of us stands," while Afghan lawmakers agreed that Karzai's threat didn't seem serious (CNN, LAT, Pajhwok, AP). Some analysts assess that Karzai's recent anti-Western rhetoric is designed to shore him up at home after an abrupt recent visit by U.S. President Barack Obama (AP). The Afghan president's trip to Washington on May 12 is still on.

A love for the ages?

The much-discussed marriage between the Indian tennis star Sania Mirza and Pakistani cricketer Shoaib Malik might be postponed from April 15 after an Indian woman claiming to be his first wife recently came forward (ToI, Bloomberg, CNN). Malik says he wed the first wife over the phone in 2002, but claims the union isn't valid because the photos he was sent before their telephone marriage were not actually of her, and they've never met.

Sign up here to receive the daily brief in your inbox. Follow the AfPak Channel on Twitter and Facebook.

A Majeed/AFP/Getty Images

 

ALI S

9:00 PM ET

April 7, 2010

Honesty and transparency - READ NOW

Dear Katherine Tiedmann,

During the run up to the Iraq war, the American press and "establishment" was accused of group think as the purported cause of this massive strategic (not really intelligence) failure.
Reporters for the NYT (eg. Judith Miller) & others routinely wrote articles that were false or misleading to the American public. This led to lack of transparency in our foreign policy, group think, deception, etc... Whatever one may call it - it was a strategic failure and a huge cost in blood & treasure to Americans and Iraqis.

You and other journalists have to be better and more careful about Afghanistan and Karzai. Please do your homework (due diligence) as a professional.

1. Please investigate for your own education and then report for our education why Mr. Peter Galbraith was fired. It is poor journalism to quote a person who has a serious deficiency in credibility ( think Ahmed Chalabi). Mr. Galbraith also demonstrated questionable ethics in Iraq ( his conflct of interest in helping write the Iraq constitution while owning stock worth tens of millions in companies who would benefit from Kurdish oil is as example).

2. Educate yourself about the polling done by the IRI in Afghanistan prior to the election last year. How does one do credible polling in a nation with a 70% illiteracy rate among males, greater than 90% among females, and not much of a telephone system or electricity in the rural areas. How were these "accurate" polls done? What is the IRI? Does it have an agenda? Can it be manipulated?

3. Mr. Karzai has risked his life to be president of Afghanistan. There is no proof, evidence, or data to indicate he is corrupt or doing this for monetary gain. No evidence - curious? His brother is on the CIA payroll and may be corrupt. There is much corruption in this broken and war torn land. But the corruption is no more than Pakistan (Mr. 10% Zardari is the president after all, and the corrupt generals are extraordinary wealthy based on stolen US aid and narcotics).

I could go on, but please consider doing your due diligence on just these 3 points. Reflexive reporting and analysis leads to group think. This leads to bad policy, and this leads to human suffering.
Good Luck. Americans deserve better.