The AFPAK Channel
Inside the war for central asia Twitter Facebook RSS
Daily Brief Latest from the Blog Latest from FP

Could Helmand be the Dubai of Afghanistan?

By Jean MacKenzie Share

Known as an insurgent hotbed and the heroin capital of the world, Afghanistan's troubled Helmand province has been given more than a few headline-grabbing labels over the past few years. Now, Helmand's governor is trying to add a new one: the next Dubai. After nearly four years at the epicenter of conflict, this dusty, downtrodden bit of desert is poised to make a bid for massive development that, according to its governor, Gulab Mangal, will radically transform it. Such a shift would go a long way to justifying the international intervention and contribute to the crucial goal of winning Afghans' hearts and minds. With U.S. President Barack Obama's proposed drawdown barely a year in the future, however, Helmand is faced with a very short window to build lasting change.

Judging from a recent trip I took to the capital, Lashkar Gah, much progress has already been made. The roads in the capital have been paved, cutting down on the ubiquitous fine sand that once clogged machinery, stifled lungs, and polluted food. Buildings are going up, more and more businesses and private organizations are opening branches in Lashkar Gah, and there are almost daily commercial flights in and out of the Lashkar Gah airport. A brand-new shopping mall and hotel are being built. The Afghan police have a shiny new compound, and the Department of Women's Affairs has been given a large center on the town's outskirts, an area that would have been too dangerous to visit one year ago.

Despite the occasional Taliban attack inside the city, there is an air of calm and security in the capital. Women and children can be seen on the streets, shops have a distinct bustle, and I felt a sense of hope and promise in the air. In the summer of 2007 I couldn't walk around the downtown area without a burqa; on this trip I fastened my headscarf a little more tightly and spent some time in the bazaar, poking around bolts of brightly colored fabric and contemplating an update to my wardrobe. I attracted a crowd -- mostly young boys who wanted to shake my hand while lisping "salaam," but no hostility, no nervous glances to see who might be watching. This, too, is a big change.

Mangal has plans to turn the single paved strip of runway in Helmand into a regional hub for air operations. Landlocked and remote, Helmand has little access to regional or international markets. But if all goes according to the governor's outline -- Mangal is building a fruit-processing plant on the airport grounds, giving farmers a convenient destination for their produce -- industry will bloom, turning Helmand's abundant fruit into gold, or at least juice suitable for export.

Another sign of hope is the declining state of the local poppy industry. Poppy cultivation took a giant dip last year, and the government is confidently predicting another significant decrease this season. Two years ago there was a large field of beautiful pink and white poppies growing in the shadow of the British military base, right inside the Lashkar Gah city limits. Now it would take a drive of several hours to find a major crop.

It's not yet clear what sparked the move away from drugs, but Mangal claims that his Food Zone program, a complex counternarcotics approach combining alternative livelihood with punitive measures for violators, along with a wide-ranging public awareness campaign, is responsible.

It is true that farmers inside the Food Zone, which includes the most fertile and highly populated areas of central Helmand, are reluctant to grow poppy -- perhaps because they will lose the wheat seeds and fertilizer the government is providing, or maybe because of the mandatory jail time.

But the Food Zone program ran into difficulties last year, when several of its top administrators were arrested for corruption. Thousands of fictitious names were added to lists of beneficiaries, allowing those in charge to claim tens of thousands of dollars for themselves; poor-quality wheat seeds were distributed to farmers while the funders were charged for premium grade, yielding nearly $1 million in illegal profits. The scandal has tainted the project, especially for farmers who were denied benefits while those with connections were able to cash in.

And the decline in the trade is probably more due to the fact that growing poppy in Helmand just isn't a smart business decision anymore. In the past three years, the price of a kilo of raw opium has dropped from about $140 to $35 -- mostly because of overproduction -- and isn't expected to rise again anytime soon.

If the government can establish permanent control over much of the province, poppy cultivation will fall. But despite encouraging signs, Helmand province is still, largely, a war zone, and the government and coalition forces have to do more than pave roads and undercut the poppy trade to change that. Despite the governor's claims that his forces have "influence" over up to 90 percent of the province, wide swaths of Helmand are still firmly under Taliban control -- districts like Washir, Dishu, Baghran, and Sangin, where the insurgents can recover, regroup, and plan their next steps.

The Afghan government and foreign forces say their military incursions have focused first on the more heavily populated areas; certainly Washir and Dishu have just a few thousand families. But Sangin is a major center and will require a great deal of effort to subdue.

Meanwhile, Musa Qala, a hotly disputed district that changed hands three times in just over a year, from October 2006 to December 2007, is still up for grabs, though the government asserts that it is completely under control. A combined British, U.S., and Afghan force took it back from the Taliban in December 2007, promising aid and development. Now, more than two years later, Afghan government forces grumble privately that they control no more than a 400-square-meter plot in the district center. Promises fell through, commitments failed, and the Taliban were able to reassert their influence over most of the district.

Marjah, the drug bazaar and heroin-processing center that was site of the major recent offensive, has now been downgraded to a "tactical prelude" to the Kandahar operation planned for the summer. The easy assumption is that Marjah has been "sorted" -- with 15,000 Afghan and foreign forces pitted against a handful of insurgents, it could hardly have appeared otherwise.

But it's dangerous to treat the Taliban like an occupying army that can be driven out with guns and bombs. They are, as we are now hearing more and more, part of the fabric of Afghan society.

"The former Taliban are now participating in cash-for-work programs, cleaning out ditches, and cleaning their shops," Mangal said. "This shows they have reintegrated back into society."

It's probably not accurate to say that the Taliban have reintegrated back into society. Instead, they know they are outnumbered, and they are biding their time. They may have removed their black pajj -- the typical Taliban headgear -- and replaced them with more neutrally colored lunghi, or turbans, but they have not changed their strategy, or their determination.

"The Taliban are building their nests again, [in Marjah]," Mohammad Ilyas Dayee, a prominent local journalist, told me recently. He thinks that insurgents are just lying low, waiting for a chance to show their power once the foreigners have moved on. " "They are lying in wait in houses, with their guns and their explosives. They go out at night to shoot foreign forces and plant mines, then they are quiet during the day," he said. "Marjah is not secure."

Part of Gen. Stanley McChrystal's revised counterinsurgency strategy is designed to cement military gains with a charm offensive to win hearts and minds. Night raids have been almost abandoned and house searches greatly reduced in frequency. But this also gives the insurgents the time and space they need to regroup, even within Marjah.

Although the window is small, there is still time. If foreign troops can rehabilitate their image in the eyes of a hostile population, then they might be able to make some real progress. If the government can convince its local constituents that it is serious about fighting corruption and encouraging development, and if the Taliban can be exposed as an anachronistic irrelevancy, then Helmand's hardheaded, pragmatic residents might decide to cast their lot with the central authorities.

But if promises turn out to be hollow, as they have so many times before, the Taliban are always there with their rough and ready justice, their guarantee of security for poppy harvests, and their long knives sharpened against "spies."

There is some reason to be hopeful. Lashkar Gah's transformation shows that Helmand's residents are more than ready to pitch in and build a better future if they have the opportunity. But there's much more reason to be cautious. If we lose Helmand, then we will never be able to claim victory in Afghanistan.

BEHROUZ MEHRI/AFP/Getty Images

EXPLORE:AFGHANISTAN
 
Facebook|Twitter|Reddit

LITTLEMANTATE

5:18 PM ET

March 19, 2010

More like a Little Saigon to Kabul's Big Saigon

Where is all the start-up money coming from? Gates' et al's little Potemkin village will collapse the minute US cash stops flowing its way. Do they think Afghanistan, off to an artificial economic start, with massive environmental and educational issues, will eventually be another Dubai? Listen, Dubai wouldn't be nothing without the oil, and it will go back to being nothing after the oil is gone. And remember the cash-cow for all this Afghan building,, the real US economy not the fake-government one, is slowly being hollowed out. That's the problem with the Pentagon and State Department- economic geniuses they ain't. The whole US government philosophy in all of this is hypocritical and contradictory to the point of being silly- neoliberalism at home, but socialism abroad? I understand what works in one country won't in another, but why don't the neoliberal Republican hawks and Clintonian democrats Congress admit that big government (their favorite whipping boy domestically) is supposed to be the panacea for all Afghanistan's woes?

 

KENNETH SORENSEN

2:48 AM ET

March 20, 2010

Dream on ---- been there before, done that

It seems Mrs. Mackenzie doesn't know the recent history of Helmand. It was for many years the centrepiece of American foreign aid and development, and as the following story makes clear, it was due to these American initiatives that the soil in Helmand got saturated with salt, but this incidentially proved beneficial for the cultivation of opium poppies. This is all decribed in a report in 2006 from The United Nations Office on Drug and Crime' and the World Bank, called "Afghan’s Drug Industry. Structure, Functioning, Dynamics and Implications for Counter-Narcotics''.

The report states: »the often controversial history about the water system in Helmand-Arghandab … and the modernisation of the Afghan state as a show case is well known … The irony of course is, that the plan that was thought as a generator for agricultural products based on cotton, actually has succeeded in generating such a market, but with the wrong crop (opium)...«. (Please click on title to go to the full story)

T-h-e--- U-n-t--o-l-d --s-t-o-r-y--- a-b-o-u-t ---H-e-l-m-a-n-d

by Karl-Johann Hemmersham and
Henrik Skovgaard Nielsen
(historians, retired from
The National Museum of Denmark)

Translated by Kenneth Sorensen

The Kajaki Dam was constructed in 1953, and if one tries to check the facts about this project, the skeletons almost come tumbling out of the closet. In the late 1940's the Afghan king wanted his country to take a leap forward towards modernity, and the American company ''Morrison Knudsen'' was commissioned to build a dam across the Helmand river. The company had previously constructed dams in The United States in the 1930's under Roosevelt's New Deal. According to the company's prospect, the intention was to build a "Little America" in Helmand;
the project included construction of a freeway across the desert to the newly build city, ''Lashgar Gah'', which was planned like a typical American suburb complete with single family houses with open lawns in front. The citizens wore American fashion-designed clothes, and a cinema, a radio-studio and a radio- and recordstore were build as well.For this reason The US Department of Agriculture suggested that some small farmers should be removed by force, and their land joined together.
In some cases, the bulldozers were shot at, and USAID reported back to Washington about the difficulties.

*
*
Unfortunately a drought resulted in a food-crisis, which in turn played a part in the destabilising of the Afghan king and his government, which was ousted in a coup in 1973.
*
*
The decay in infrastructure and agriculture continued under the Soviet occupation. The soil was still saturated with salt, but this incidentially proved beneficial for the cultivation of opium poppies. This is all decribed in a report in 2006 from The United Nations Office on Drug and Crime' and the World Bank, called "Afghan’s Drug Industry. Structure, Functioning, Dynamics and Implications for Counter-Narcotics''.

The report states: »the often controversial history about the water system in Helmand-Arghandab … and the modernisation of the Afghan state as a show case is well known … The irony of course is, that the plan that was thought as a generator for agricultural products based on cotton, actually has succeeded in generating such a market, but with the wrong crop (opium)...«.

 

KENNETH SORENSEN

2:53 AM ET

March 20, 2010

So due to American efforts, opium is the only crop that can grow

So what are we to make of the recent initiatives to more or less force the farmers to grow wheat. I don't think Mrs. Mackenzie is intentially fooling us - the most informed people on the face of the Earth.

It is more likely that she simply doesn't know the full story and just wrote something on the basis of what she knew, which was, alas, very limited.

 

RSCOTT

11:09 AM ET

April 2, 2010

Central Helmand Irrigation

I think it is you that needs to do a bit more reading on this irrigation system. MacKenzie's report appears to be right on. The irrigation system did not salt the land. It has to do with the passage of the water through the soils...drainage. With 4 inches of rain a year and some 100+ inches of evaporation, the trick is to get the irrigation water to tricle down through the soil rather than to move the other way, up, and bring the salts with it. And cotton is still cultivated in the area. The British built government cotton gin is still functioning but the community of international doners have shown no interest in supporting this cash crop that the farmers of at least Nad-i-Ali (some 30,000+ acres of irrigated land) have been requesting help with since at least 97 as one of the possible alternative crops to poppy. The US cotton lobby restricts the use of US foreign aid funds from being used in support of any cotton industry any place in the world no matter how small or how important it might be as competition with opium poppy.
The work started to develop the central Helmand irrigation system was with Japanese and German support in the 1930s, stopped by the war. In 1946 Morrison-Knutsen construction went in to restart the work on the irrigation system, not the dam that came later. The irrigation system brought new land into cultivation from the flat desert escarpment not previously cultivated, settled thousands of farm and nomadic families which was one of the primary goals...etc etc.
For more background see my not yet completed website: www.scottshelmandvalleyarchives.org
You have a very skewed view of the Helmand valley irrigation system and dont think that the UN people know much more than you do.

 

GEORGE WALSH

1:27 PM ET

March 20, 2010

Young boys shaking hands with Mrs. Mackenzie

Mrs. Mackenzie innocently describes the desire of young boys to shake hands with her, attributing this to some form of political change. She should have looked at the excitement in their eyes.

Afghan women (like those in many other conservative countries) do not shake hands with men - it is a level of intimacy that is akin to Western women allowing strange men to fondle their exposed bum in a Super Market. Mrs. Mackenzie gave those young boys a thrill that they will remember in their dreams for years to come.

 

RICHARD01

1:05 AM ET

March 22, 2010

Lashkar Gah and the New Afghanistan

James Michener wrote a great book in 1963, called ';Caravans', set some time before the great Helmand dam was completed. As usual with Michener, it is a ripping yarn, with many interposed facts. He describes many of the Afghans' more unpleasant practices, such as stoning of adulterous women, and bloody murders of dancing boys, the difficulties of a lone German doctor unable to touch or see his women patients, and much else.
I read it first long before 9/11, and had a small insight into the realities, with a gut feeling about the American invasion's inevitable failure. Here we are, 9 years on, still with no rationale for the Afghan war, and no progress.
Innocents like Ms McKenzie may extol the slight changes that are occurring, temporarily, and may get some of them entirely wrong, like the small boys' hand-shaking, but Good Americans have just as bad effects as Ugly Americans.