Saturday, March 13, 2010 - 5:59 PM

Something strange is afoot among the
Pakistani body politic and military establishment. If you've been
reading reports and blogs, you would think the war was over, and that
Afghanistan, India, and the U.S. lost (do I really need to spell out who
won?). With a post-U.S. withdrawal scenario in Afghanistan looming, our
strategic mavens seem to be on the road to securing what they conceive
of as Pakistan's national interests, and ensuring considerable leverage
and influence in Afghanistan. It's come to the point where Hamid Karzai,
no friend of Pakistan, summed it up
thus: "India is a close friend of Afghanistan but Pakistan is a brother
of Afghanistan. Pakistan is a twin brother ... we're conjoined twins,
there's no separation." How times have changed.
This state of
affairs has meant that we get unnamed sources within the military
establishment saying things like
"We hold all the cards," talking about
securing a "strategic coup...against rising Indian influence in
Afghanistan", all the while continuing to make
territorial gains against the TTP in the tribal areas. All of this
reflects a rising confidence and sense of satisfaction with the status
quo and the trajectory of events in the region in the short and medium
term.
While I would love to share this smugness, there's a slight
problem: you see, Pakistan keeps suffering terrorist attacks. To be
sure, there are peaks (this past week, and the two month period of
October-November 2009) and valleys (first two months of this year) in
the levels of violence, but no sane, rational observer would say that
the threat of indiscriminate violence against Pakistani citizens has
dissipated in any meaningful way.
Ultimately, this is what
matters most. The job of the political and military leadership is not to secure "Pakistan's interests"
-- whatever they may be -- in Afghanistan. Such language bears an
uncanny resemblance to the neoimperialism that both our right and left
so vociferously denounce when it originates from the West. No, the job
of our political and military leadership is to ensure a robust, but by
no means perfect, level of safety for its citizens, so that they can go
about their daily lives. It's pretty simple.
This does not mean,
of course, that one should expect or hope for success in a day, week, or
month. I don't think any fair-minded reader could accuse me of
impatience with our efforts in this war. This is a long, hard slog, and
will remain so for a while, unfortunately. But my central gripe is what
those efforts seem to be geared toward, rather than immediate-term
success or failure of said efforts. I would submit that the Pakistani
public has paid a fairly steep price for the last time our brilliant
strategic minds devised their regional adventures. One hopes they have
learned their lesson.
Ahsan Butt is a PhD student in political science at the University of Chicago and contributes to the blog Five Rupees, where this was originally published.
(0)
HIDE COMMENTS LOGIN OR REGISTER REPORT ABUSE