Monday, February 15, 2010 - 8:49 AM

Event notice: Join the New America Foundation today
at 3:30pm in Washington DC for a talk by Sciences Po professor Jean
Pierre Filiu on the French view of al Qaeda and affiliated groups.
Details available here.
The fog of war
Early
Saturday morning, the international coalition began a much-anticipated
military offensive with an airlift in the Taliban stronghold town of
Marjah in the southern Afghan province of Helmand, pitting up to 15,000
Marines and soldiers against between 400 and 2,000 Taliban militants,
including up to 100 foreign fighters, in a town of some 80,000
residents (NYT, AP, Wash Post, AFP, McClatchy, Times).
The offensive was reportedly delayed one day at the request of Afghan
officials, who wanted to give tribal elders a chance to talk the
Taliban out of fighting, and coalition officers agreed although no one
expected any major defections (WSJ).
Reporting
is mixed on the progress of the offensive so far, as some outlets
report "stiff" Taliban resistance, while others say Taliban militants
have fled the area, possibly over the border to Pakistan (Wash Post, CNN, NYT, WSJ, AJE, Pajhwok, NYT).
Afghan and western officials have been mostly positive thus far, while
the Taliban have criticized coalition forces "bombing and launching
rockets on Marjah... bothering" the people (WSJ).
As
many as 12 civilians were killed Sunday after Afghan troops came under
intense small-arms fire from a mud-walled compound and the returning
rockets missed their intended target, landing about 300 hundred yards
away (NYT, AFP, CNN, Pajhwok, AP, Times, BBC, Guardian, Wash Post).
Marjah's heavily mined roads have meant slow going for coalition
troops, and war correspondent Rajiv Chandrasekaran reports that it took
a platoon of Marines nine hours to walk one mile yesterday, and
Christopher Torchia recounts a firefight in the Badula Qulp region of
Helmand (AP, WSJ, Wash Post, AP, LAT).
Karen
DeYoung assesses that the Marjah offensive is a major test of the Obama
administration's strategy in Afghanistan, while Matthew Rosenberg
writes that it represents a major test for Afghan President Hamid
Karzai and his fledgling Afghan army (Wash Post, WSJ).
Dexter Filkins and David Sanger analyze the strategy behind the
offensive, and reporter C. J. Chivers and war photographers Tyler Hicks
and Bryan Denton document the operation and tactics (NYT, NYT, NYT, WSJ, NYT).
As
Operation Moshtarak ("Together" in Dari) enters its third day,
coalition forces are facing teams of Taliban snipers, though U.S.
officials say Marines are making "steady progress" throughout the area
and the senior Afghan commander for the operation stated that Nad Ali
and Marjah are "almost all" under control (Reuters, AFP, AP).
Afghan and NATO officials have also been holding meetings with local
leaders in Marjah, to help pave the way for a permanent government
presence (NYT).
Kidnappings and elections
On
Sunday, the Afghan Taliban released a video of two French journalists
who were kidnapped in Kapisa at the end of December, showing the two
men pleading with their government to negotiate (AFP). Several Afghan employees were also taken, and French media has not disclosed the names of the reporters captured.
And
the Afghan government has drafted a revised election law that would
substantially limit the number of women allowed to serve in the lower
house of Afghanistan's parliament, remove the three foreign members
from the five-person body that investigates electoral fraud, and
proposes a series of qualifications for would-be presidents (Wash Post).
These qualifications include having a bachelor's degree, a "good
reputation," and being a "wise and brave person" unaffected by "psychic
diseases."
Drones and protests in Pakistan
Two
suspected U.S. drone strikes in as many days have hit villages in the
restive tribal region of North Waziristan in northwest Pakistan,
killing several alleged militants in the first reported strikes in
nearly two weeks (AP, Reuters, AFP; NYT, CNN, AFP, Reuters, Geo, AJE, Dawn).
A suspected drone strike is believed to have mortally wounded
Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) chief Hakimullah Mehsud in mid-January,
and the militant group has not produced evidence that he is still alive
in almost a month, though local commanders continue to deny his death (The News). "I am dead sure he is alive," one claimed on Saturday.
Political
tension is simmering in Pakistan, as the country's Supreme Court
rejected two judicial appointments late Saturday, only hours after the
unpopular Pakistani President Asif Ali Zardari announced them --
allegedly without the approval of the Supreme Court's Chief Justice,
Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudry, whose consultation is required by the
Pakistani constitution (NYT, AP, WSJ, AFP, AJE).
Pakistan's leading opposition figure, Nawaz Sharif, chimed in to call
Zardari "the biggest threat to democracy," and many Pakistani lawyers
have boycotted courts today to protest Zardari's decision, which pits
the embattled president against the powerful chief justice (Reuters, Dawn). Pro-government lawyers also took to the streets in some cities.
The Washington Post
takes a look at the Obama administration's apparent emphasis on
targeted killings instead of captures for militant targets, determining
that improved surveillance technology, a decrease in options for where
to keep potential captives, and an increase in such attacks appears to
have "tipped the balance in that direction" (Wash Post). And the National
reports that civilian reconstruction in Pakistan's Swat Valley, the
site of a major Pakistani military offensive last year, is struggling
to take off (National).
The artsy type
The
Center for Contemporary Art Afghanistan, established four years ago to
help preserve historic documents, put on a day-long show yesterday
featuring photographs, paintings, and art films put together by Afghan
women (Pajhwok). The CCAA has trained 60 women in the arts and has 30 more still learning.
Sign up here to receive the daily brief in your inbox.
It's been widely reported that Marjah is a town of 80,00 people. It is a village in the middle of a complex of hamlets and farms. Five minutes on Google will tell you that.
The reports of hundreds or thousands of Taliban fighters slugging it out with coalition troops is a ludicrous exaggeration. The whole thing is a PR exercise and the Western media has swallowed it hook, line and sinker.
I'm sure that the locals appreciate thousands of heavily armed troops blundering around blowing up goats and haystacks
Marjah's heavily mined roads have meant slow going for coalition troops and war correspondent Rajiv Chandrasekaran reports that it took a platoon of Marines nine hours to walk one mile. The Marjah offensive is a major test of the Obama administration's strategy in Afghanistan. These two sentences, when conflated, force on to conclude WHAT are they thinking?! Now add 15,000 troops vs 400- 2,000 Taliban with hapless civilians in between and the ubiquitous mountains into which the Taliban disappear: seems like an unsound strategy with no positive outcome. Obama, Mullen and McChrystal are, frankly, not playing with a full deck. If they manage to find a silver lining in this offensive I'll be surprised.
(2)
HIDE COMMENTS LOGIN OR REGISTER REPORT ABUSE