Thursday, November 19, 2009 - 9:08 AM

Wonk Watch: AfPak
Channel editor and New America Foundation senior fellow Peter Bergen is
testifying before the House Committee on Homeland Security this morning
on the evolving threat from al Qaeda to the United States. His
testimony is available here and a webcast will be available here at 10:00am EST. If you would like us to consider featuring your research in Wonk Watch, email it to tiedemann@newamerica.net.
High expectations
Nearly
three months after the fraud-plagued election, Afghan President Hamid
Karzai was inaugurated into his second five year term, saying that he
wants Afghan security forces to be under full Afghan control within
five years and called for a loya jirga, or traditional council of
elders, to address the insurgent threat and the country's pervasive
corruption (BBC, Washington Post, AFP, Pajhwok).
In a speech that hit many of the same notes he struck during the
presidential campaign, Karzai called for his erstwhile presidential
rival Abdullah Abdullah to join a national unity government and also
reached out to Taliban fighters for reconciliation (Times of London).
Excerpts
of Karzai's inauguration speech, which was attended by some 800 Afghan
and foreign dignitaries, are available from the BBC (BBC, New York Times).
The Taliban, for their part, dismissed the inauguration as "not a
historic day" and called Kabul a "government based on nothing," though
initial foreign reaction was more positive (AP).
Security in the Afghan capital today was tight and the mood tense, as
the government declared a holiday and encouraged Afghan and
international workers alike to stay home out of fears over militant
attacks (Al Jazeera, Foreign Policy, Los Angeles Times).
And
indeed, Afghan officials say a pair of suicide bombs in neighboring
Uruzgan and Zabul provinces in southern Afghanistan killed at least ten
civilians and two U.S. soldiers at around the same time Karzai was
being inaugurated (AP, AFP, Reuters).
A
key concern of the international community is the levels of corruption
in Afghanistan, and U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton delivered
"what amounted to a stern pep talk to a nervous partner" to Karzai,
saying in private to the president that future civilian aid from the
U.S. would depend in part on how well the government addressed
corruption (New York Times, Reuters).
Clinton later told reporters that Kabul has not done "nearly enough to
demonstrate a seriousness of purpose to tackle corruption" (New York Times, Washington Post, Pajhwok).
Part of addressing the corruption problem will be rooting out the
cronyism that has pervaded the government, and Karzai is facing rising
calls from Afghans, Western donors, and the United States to replace
many of the warlords who supported him during the election season (New York Times).
The cost of doing business?
A prime example of the scope of
Afghanistan's corruption problem is the case of the Afghan minister of
mines, who reportedly accepted a bribe of $30 million in exchange for
awarding the country's largest development project to a Chinese firm (Washington Post, Times of London, AP).
Muhammad Ibrahim Adel allegedly accepted the bribe in Dubai in late
2007, when the state-run China Metallurgical Group Corp. won the nearly
$3 billion bid to extract copper from the Aynak deposit, considered one
of the world's largest 'unexploited' copper deposits, in Logar
province. In a press conference yesterday, Adel vehemently denied the
accusation and is considering suing the Washington Post, which broke
the story (Pajhwok).
Corruption,
violence, and political uncertainty may cause a massive capital flight
from Afghanistan, according to Al Jazeera, which reports that many
Afghan business owners are already moving their assets overseas to the
Gulf where the economies are safer (Al Jazeera).
Another reason for the exodus is the recent increase in kidnappings for
ransom of the relatives of wealthy Afghan businessmen.
Afghanistan's other elections
And
in an under-covered story, McClatchy checks in on the status of
Afghanistan's provincial elections -- which occurred on the same day as
the presidential balloting in August and suffered from similar problems
of fraud and threats of violence -- to find that many of the
provincial-level contests remain unresolved (McClatchy).
The U.N.-backed body charged with investigating complaints about the
election is still considering 640 high-priority claims before issuing
final verdicts.
Afghanistan's election drama comes as the United
States is contemplating a new plan for the country, the debate around
which has recently shifted toward an exit strategy, which worries some
lawmakers like Rep. Ike Skelton (D-MI), who said of the Taliban that
"they'll just wait us out" (Wall Street Journal).
Senior officials say, however, that U.S. President Barack Obama is not
calling for publicly declared handover dates, but rather "key
milestones" for the country to meet.
An explosive attack
In
the eighth major attack since the beginning of the month, a suicide
bomber who arrived in a taxi and detonated his explosives while being
searched by Pakistani police at the entrance of a courthouse in
Peshawar killed at least 19 and wounded more than 50 (AP, Dawn, Geo TV, Reuters, BBC).
The capital of the Northwest Frontier Province, Peshawar, has been hard
hit by attacks that picked up speed in early October ahead of the
Pakistani military's operations in the militant stronghold of South
Waziristan (AP, Bloomberg). The spate of violence has left more than 400 Pakistanis dead.
A
spokesman for the Pakistani Taliban, in a news conference yesterday in
a secret location in South Waziristan, told a handful of reporters that
the militant group had not retreated, as the Army has claimed, but
instead said, "We have voluntarily withdrawn into the mountains under a
strategy that will trap the Pakistan army in the area" (AFP, Dawn, The News). Some 550 militants have reportedly been killed since the operations began.
In
the United States' 46th alleged drone strike in Pakistan this year,
several missiles were fired at a suspected Taliban compound in the
tribal agency of North Waziristan, killing several reported militants
in the Shana Khuwara village close to the South Waziristan border (Geo TV, Reuters, BBC, Dawn, AP).
There have been no reports of drone strikes in South Waziristan,
previously a frequent target of the CIA-operated missiles, since the
Pakistani military's offensive began on October 17.
The U.S.
expects to complete a review of how to spend the $7.5 billion in aid
for Pakistan by the end of November, focusing on the country's
"decrepit" energy sector, which economists say undermines potential for
growth and weakens the already-shaky civilian government (Reuters).
It is not yet known precisely how the $1.5 billion per year will be
allocated, but officials say infrastructure projects are an "important
part" of the review.
Complicated connections
Indian
officials are investigating whether two men, recently arrested in
Chicago on terrorism charges related to planning an attack on a Danish
newspaper that in 2005 published cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad, have
connections to the November 2008 Mumbai terrorist attacks that left
more than 160 dead (New York Times, Washington Post).
David Coleman Headley and Tahawwur Hussain Rana -- a U.S. and a
Canadian citizen, respectively -- are also accused of reporting to
Ilyas Kashmiri, a onetime Pakistani military officer turned Islamist
militant commander associated with both al Qaeda and Lashkar-e-Taiba,
and conspiring with another as-yet-unnamed former Pakistani military
official, in one of the first cases in which authorities have seemed to
link suspects directly to former officers, though such connections have
long been suspected.
And in almost a dozen recent terrorism
cases in the U.S., U.K., and Canada, investigators have discovered a
common thread among the suspects: devotion to messages from the radical
U.S.-born Yemeni cleric Anwar al-Aulaqi, who has apparently used the
internet to useful effect in radicalization (New York Times). Aulaqi has been linked to the Fort Hood and Fort Dix attacks, among others.
Happily ever later
Thousands
of Pakistanis have demanded that the government of Punjab province not
implement a recently passed resolution to stop performing marriage
ceremonies after 10:00pm (The News). The neighboring Sindh government allows marriage ceremonies until 12:00am, and the protesters want Punjab to follow suit.
Sign up here to receive the daily brief in your inbox.
SHAH MARAI/AFP/Getty Images
I recently attended a panel discussion on US policy in Afghanistan-Pakistan at a local university. After perspectives on domestic, European, and International issues, a Pakistani student presented her views. I was struck by her heart for her people. She ended with a plea to realize the short term dangers in the current use of drones. She stressed that we may win by dismantling the current leadership structure; yet we end up converting moderate Pakistanis to more extreme views.
The last presenter spoke of education diplomacy--Pakistani students in the US gained valuable leadership experience and perspectives on democracy. He ended his presentation with an email from one such student who had returned home to the FATA region. He had been told of the dangers to his life because he was viewed as a threat by some in the area. A threat because the climate is increasingly hostile due in part to drone attacks.
Tiedemann and Bergen (Pakistan drone war takes a toll on militants -- and civilians) argue that the drone strategy is working and is the best option on the table.
I contend it is not working. It is not only likely to be illegal, is it unethical. Put differently, would you strike down a key terrorist leader if you knew you would kill your son or daughter? Would you make such a move if you knew that because at least one innocent person would die that you would create 5 more extremist to take the one leaders place?
I would like to identify others seeking to influence policy away from drone attacks. The ethics, the legality, and the efficacy of these attacks indicate the need for other steps.
(1)
HIDE COMMENTS LOGIN OR REGISTER REPORT ABUSE